Bastar: The Naxal Story Film Evaluation



critic’s ranking: 



2.5/5

The principle character of the story is Neerja Madhavan (Adah Sharma), a critical police officer in a high-ranking place within the CRPF, tasked with stopping the Naxal revolt. The film begins in a courtroom the place the federal government and Naxal representatives are preventing in court docket. Neerja makes use of Particular Police Officers (SPOs) and a government-backed group referred to as Salwa Judum to cease the Naxalites in Chhattisgarh. On the identical time, we observe the story of Ratna (Indira Tiwari), a tribal girl whose husband was brutally killed by a well-known Naxalite named Lanka Reddy. In search of revenge, Ratna joins the police pressure and helps Neerja in her mission.

Bastar: The Naxal Story affords a one-dimensional perspective on the complicated problem of Naxalism, presenting them solely as anti-national components with out delving into the intricacies of the issue. The movie falls quick in offering a nuanced understanding, because it paints all left-wing ideologies and liberal politics as inherently anti-national, overlooking the range of views inside these realms. Furthermore, the portrayal of intellectuals and journalists as collaborators in undermining nationwide integrity lacks depth and fails to discover the multifaceted roles these people play in society. It factors fingers at universities similar to JNU (although it’s not named as such), saying it’s a den of anti-nationals. And likewise alludes {that a} sure social gathering, with its Gandhian thought-base, is detrimental to the wellbeing of the nation and is sponsoring terrorism through Naxals. The film compares the Maoist revolt to teams like Islamic State and Boko Haram. It additionally suggests connections between the leaders of the Naxal motion and organisations similar to Lashkar-e-Toiba, Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam, and Filipino communist teams.

The narrative additionally makes an attempt to attribute an enchancment within the state of affairs post-2010 to the efforts of the current authorities. This oversimplification neglects the contributions and challenges confronted by varied stakeholders in addressing the Naxal problem. Moreover, the movie’s use of graphic scenes, such because the preliminary decapitation scene, could also be extreme and doubtlessly alienating to some viewers. Whereas such depictions can serve to focus on the severity of the violence related to Naxalism, their gratuitous nature dangers overshadowing the underlying message of the movie.

Adah Sharma’s portrayal of a devoted police officer is effectively inside the bounds of the script. At instances, it turns into too loud. General, Bastar: The Naxal Story falls quick in offering a balanced and nuanced portrayal of its subject material, opting as an alternative for a sensationalised narrative that fails to seize the complexities of the difficulty at hand.

Trailer : Bastar: The Naxal Story Film Evaluation

Abhishek Srivastava, March 15, 2024, 1:30 PM IST


critic’s ranking: 



3.0/5


Story: Drawing inspiration from precise occasions, this movie delves into the Naxal menace within the state of Chhattisgarh, showcasing the extraordinary efforts of a single police officer who went above and past to quell the Naxal menace.

Evaluation: With ‘Bastar: The Naxal Story,’ director Sudipto Sen and producer Vipul Amrutlal Shah try to make clear one more societal problem. Following the field workplace success of ‘The Kerala Story,’ their focus now shifts to the Naxal insurgency in Chhattisgarh. Whereas “Bastar” engages audiences for a lot of its period, a deeper exploration of the political panorama may have enhanced the narrative, and made this a finer watch. Drawing inspiration from real-life incidents and characters, the movie injects a fictional essence into its portrayal. Regardless of a screenplay that lacks power, Sen compensates along with his skilful depiction of occasions, however be forewarned that there are moments within the movie which may be tough to look at.
The focus of the story is Neerja Madhavan (Adah Sharma), a no-nonsense IPS officer holding a senior CRPF place tasked with quashing the Naxal insurgency. The movie begins in a courtroom the place authorities and Naxal representatives are engaged in a authorized battle. Neerja employs Particular Police Officers (SPOs) and the state-run militia, Salwa Judum, to curb Naxal affect in Chhattisgarh. Operating parallel to that is the story of Ratna (Indira Tiwari), a tribal girl whose husband was gruesomely killed by Lanka Reddy (Vijay Krishna), a infamous Naxalite. In search of retribution, Ratna enrols and trains to change into a Particular Police Officer and aids Neerja in her mission.

The movie incorporates characters primarily based on actual people, though with altered names, resulting in a guessing sport for viewers accustomed to the precise occasions. The movie’s life like tone is complemented by becoming areas. All through the movie, its gritty ambiance retains audiences on the sting, significantly in scenes the place the ‘influential elite’ provide their assist to the Naxalites. A major oversight lies within the absence of depicting Delhi and Raipur as central management hubs. In a story of this nature, delving into the behind-the-scenes operations of those centres turns into essential. Whereas the movie touches on these components, it merely scratches the floor. Moreover, whereas the movie is well-shot, the loud background music serves as a distraction.

As soon as once more, Adah Sharma shines in a commanding function, paying homage to her spectacular efficiency in ‘The Kerala Story.’ Portraying an uncompromising police officer, she delivers a honest portrayal, unafraid to talk her thoughts even within the presence of politicians. Indira Tiwari, embodying a tribal girl, delivers a heartfelt efficiency that resonates deeply. Vijay Krishna’s portrayal of Lanka Reddy, adeptly switching between English and Hindi, exudes menace, whereas Raima Sen, Shilpa Shukla, and Yashpal Sharma match their respective roles completely. ‘Bastar’ is a hard-hitting crime drama, with moments that certainly shake you.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *