COMAC can problem Airbus, Boeing’s sooner or later—but it surely will not be straightforward


When a panel flew out of its Alaska Airways 737 Max 9 aircraft mid-air in January, the security requirements and management at Boeing grew to become front-and-center. It’s since seen a slower tempo of manufacturing and deliveries have additional slipped behind for the market chief and its German rival, Airbus. 

Because the Seattle-based plane maker offers with the fallout from the accident whereas navigating its seek for a brand new CEO, it’s prompted discussions on whether or not a 3rd contender might fly into a world aviation market dominated by Airbus and Boeing—notably, Chinese language state-backed COMAC.

The China-based airline maker has been working for nicely over a decade to construct a challenger business plane that may shake up Boeing and Airbus’s stronghold. COMAC continues to be small, on condition that solely 5 of its plane are flown by one of many nation’s greatest carriers, China Japanese Airways. However a scarcity of planes amid excessive journey demand, shaky standing for Boeing, and C919’s grand debut in Singapore final month all level to a gap within the aviation market that would work in COMAC’s favor because it eyes a slice of the aviation pie. 

What’s COMAC all about?

The Chinese language group first started engaged on its narrowbody airliner in 2008, and manufacturing started three years after. Its C919 jets are actually seen as potential rivals to Boeing’s 737s in addition to Airbus’s 320 liners. They had been licensed by the aviation authority in China in Sep. 2022, and flew their first planes commercially inside its home-country a yr in the past. 

The plane maker’s aim has all the time been to unseat the 2 behemoths, and high airline trade executives have acknowledged COMAC’s potential as a competitor. In 2024, aviation consultancy IBA estimates that COMAC will ship 9 jets—that’s lower than a 3rd of Boeing’s month-to-month deliveries, pointing to the tall process the Chinese language group faces. 

However it’s already receiving extra curiosity from airline corporations, and will acquire share inside China and the remainder of Asia earlier than setting its eyes on the remainder of the world.  

“The challenges Boeing is going through have introduced extra give attention to the alternatives that lie forward for COMAC. The query is can COMAC make the most of Boeing’s weakened place within the near-term?” Mike Yeomans, director of valuations and consulting at IBA, instructed Fortune.

IBA’s estimates level to COMAC grabbing 4% of worldwide narrowbody deliveries, giving it somewhat over 1% of the market share by 2030. Whereas which will take years to ramp up thereafter, it’s a begin helped by Boeing’s uncertainties and the urge for food for journey. Airbus has additionally benefited from these tendencies, because it’s gained market share amid the continuing disaster.  

Yeomans additionally famous that with Airbus and Boeing’s narrowbodies bought out for a lot of this decade, “the C919 has a powerful alternative to realize market share, notably in its home market.” 

It’s nonetheless unclear if Boeing’s woes have straight propped up demand for COMAC’s plane.    

Will COMAC make strides… quickly?

Whereas there are extra tailwinds for COMAC now than earlier than, one of many greatest challenges for COMAC is getting licensed by main authorities exterior China. The China-based group’s affect is pretty restricted for now particularly as a result of it isn’t licensed with U.S. and European regulators, and that’s vital if it hopes to be “a reputable menace to the present duopoly within the world narrowbody market” Yeomans mentioned. 

One other lingering query is whether or not COMAC is as much as the problem of scaling up manufacturing if demand grows.

“COMAC manufacturing charges have been far decrease and inconsistent over time, and so we might not anticipate vital near-term capability to dramatically shift the dynamics,” John Mowry from Alton Aviation Consulting instructed Fortune, referring to the ability dynamics between Airbus, Boeing and COMAC. Nonetheless, he added that within the medium and long-term there’s scope for “vital demand” within the narrowbody plane market.

The mark COMAC makes with its present and upcoming clients when it comes to high quality management, well timed supply and extra might additionally decide whether or not it has a future in breaking apart the management shared by its German and American counterparts.

“The extent to which it displaces alternatives for Airbus and Boeing will depend upon its in-service efficiency and reliability at launch operator China Japanese, and others as they begin to take deliveries.”

All of the skepticism apart, issues are brewing at COMAC—it revealed two sorts of C919s which can be within the works and acquired 50 jet orders from Tibet Airways in February. It could possibly be some time earlier than COMAC breaks a duopoly up, but it surely appears to have gotten a tiny foot within the door for now.

Subscribe to the brand new Fortune CEO Weekly Europe e-newsletter to get nook workplace insights on the most important enterprise tales in Europe. Join totally free.